Influence of social media: New York wants to protect children
: How New York wants to regulate social media
by Celine Schuster, New York City
30.06.2024 | 09:59 a.m.
The mental health of children in the USA is getting worse. One reason: social media. New York is passing a new law – and wants to give parents more influence. A good solution?
In the future, social media companies in New York will be required to restrict “addictive feeds” for minors. This means that children will no longer be shown such feeds – unless their parents explicitly agree.
Social networks: risk of addiction due to algorithms
Democratic state Senator Andrew Gounardes is one of the bill’s supporters. He defines “addictive feeds” as: “It’s an algorithmic feed based on what you’ve searched for, what you’ve clicked on, what you’ve commented on, and what’s on your profile.”
Dozens of US states have filed a lawsuit against the Facebook company Meta. The accusation is that Meta is knowingly endangering the health of children and young people.
25.10.2023 | 00:21 min
The algorithm would then show extreme content – psychologically speaking, this would lead to further scrolling. So it’s about interrupting the algorithm’s endless suggestions:
This bill will not block or censor any type of content, but it will prevent children from spending five or six hours a day on social media with no other purpose than simply scrolling through the posts.
Politician Gounardes assumes that this interruption will mean that minors are “exposed to much less harmful content from the outset”. However, users can still explicitly search for other people and topics that interest them. In addition to limiting suggestions, the law prohibits notifications to minors between midnight and six in the morning.
Social media law faces criticism
He is the legal director of the Surveillance Technology Oversight Project, a tech watchdog group and nonprofit organization that advocates for citizens’ concerns and provides legal advice.
The idea that we not only allow but require social media companies to engage in this kind of invasive snooping is problematic to me.
This would affect everyone, as we would have to find out who is an adult and who is not. For Siffert, this means one thing above all:
The de facto end of anonymous use of large parts of the Internet.
Senator Gounardes responds to this accusation: “Just because the program knows your age doesn’t mean it knows your name, which still leaves you anonymous. You can still have any username you want.”
Insults and harassment via the Internet or mobile phone are becoming more common. According to a WHO study, one in six school children is affected by cyberbullying.
27.03.2024 | 01:32 min
Necessary parental consent can be a problem
In addition, the necessary parental consent is problematic. “For emancipated 16- to 17-year-olds who may be in college, who may have abusive parents, who may have homophobic parents,” says data protection expert Siffert. The draft law contains an unclear definition of social media.
Siffert fears that it will come down to two things:
Parents who just click “yes” to what will happen by and large, or the parents who get upset about the kids.
Ultimately, the “addictive” feeds will continue to be played out “and the exceptions will be abusive and homophobic parents who are upset that their children are on certain websites,” Siffert said.
Cell phone addiction: Prevent it with chronological feeds
His suggestion: Companies should display their content in a non-algorithmic way by default: “Chronologically. That would strengthen the bill and also not endanger children and everyone’s privacy.” That would mean a return to feeds like Instagram and Co. had for everyone in their early days.
Many school children rush through the day and often have great difficulty relaxing and falling asleep in the evening. Parents can find numerous offers of help online. What are they worth?
06.03.2024 | 05:08 min
However, New York Attorney General Letitia James sees the law as an important step. It will “make New York a national leader in addressing the youth mental health crisis and serve as an example to other states.”
The Attorney General and her office are now working on rules and guidelines. Once these are finalized, the new law will come into effect 180 days later. According to State Senator Gounardes, by then there should also be a roadmap on how each individual app can comply with the requirements of the law. If the companies do not comply with the new rules, there could be fines of up to $5,000 per violation, among other things.
Celine Schuster works in the ZDF studio in New York City.
Ethel Purdy – Medical Blogger & Pharmacist
Bridging the world of wellness and science, Ethel Purdy is a professional voice in healthcare with a passion for sharing knowledge. At 36, she stands at the confluence of medical expertise and the written word, holding a pharmacy degree acquired under the rigorous education systems of Germany and Estonia.
Her pursuit of medicine was fueled by a desire to understand the intricacies of human health and to contribute to the community’s understanding of it. Transitioning seamlessly into the realm of blogging, Ethel has found a platform to demystify complex medical concepts for the everyday reader.
Ethel’s commitment to the world of medicine extends beyond her professional life into a personal commitment to health and wellness. Her hobbies reflect this dedication, often involving research on the latest medical advances, participating in wellness communities, and exploring the vast and varied dimensions of health.
Join Ethel as she distills her pharmaceutical knowledge into accessible wisdom, fostering an environment where science meets lifestyle and everyone is invited to learn. Whether you’re looking for insights into the latest health trends or trustworthy medical advice, Ethel’s blog is your gateway to the nexus of healthcare and daily living.